Gear Lust: Omnidirectional Speakers and the Duevel in the Blue Dress...

Duevel speakers are not the first, and certainly won't be the last omnidirectional speakers ever designed.  But they just may be the prettiest.  You can read about them here. The are currently distributed by a Canadian company, Duevel having dropped their US distributor and consolidated in Canada under the umbrella of the very interesting and self described "Zendo" as company Mutine.
Look!  That's how they do it!

Omnidirectional speakers tend to be radially symmetrical - which isn't surprising.  And the first popular success was the Ohm Walsh F.  Bose (yes that Bose) spent a lot of the 1960's trying to figure out how to do one - and eventually settled on the Bose 901's as a poly-directional speaker - 9 drivers firing to the rear, and 1 towards the listener.  I have to say, as an owner of a pair, you will not find a bigger illusion of a soundstage (but diffuse) and a convincing illusion of being at a rock concert when playing live music loudly anywhere near its price - and possibly any price.  And they play rattle-the-windows LOUD without any signs of strain that typical speakers experience. 
Bose 901: Audiophiles hate
these, but they ROCK!
One of my favorite online magazines did an audiophile review, and I think they nailed it here.  While it doesn't tick off a lot of Audiophile only boxes, you would be hard pressed to find a more fun speaker at it's price point.  And for what it's worth, it's been in production for 45 years.

In the 1970's and 1980's a lot of manufacturers experimented with
Bose 2201 - two of these in the corners
and it fills the room.  Granddaddy
of the Bose 901's - the 901 being an answer to
the question raised about what you do
when no one buys the 2201 and
you have a warehouse full of 5" drivers.
poly-directional and omnidirectional speakers, partly motivated by trying to make a better Bose 901, and partly because a large soundfield is attractive for someone who expects to have a large number of people listening to music at the same time.   If you are old enough to recall (I am!), one of the first things people did when they were on their own was get a stereo.  A big source of entertainment was having friends over and playing music, talking, drinking, and being together (This social-aspect to music playback we think is something we've lost over the years - probably as TV's got bigger and cheaper).  In such circumstances a speaker that projected its sound as widely as possible makes perfect sense.  We think that in today's family, this makes sense, too (and incidentally why we feel the current "surround sound" for "home theater" is a Rube Goldberg solution to the exact same problem).
The Ohm Walsh F
Classic speaker.  Difficult to pair with an amp,
Fragile, and the people who still own them
would kill for them.

One of the big players in the omnidirectional arena was an American Company (in Brooklyn, no less!), Ohm Speakers and their classic Ohm Walsh F speaker.  Due to numerous issues involving their difficulty and reliability in real-world conditions, it was eventually discontinued.  Ohm, though, redesigned their core technology to be an almost-omnidirectional speakers that were far easier to live with, and continue to this day.  They aren't "pure" omni speakers anymore - but its like horse-shoes and hand grenades - it's close enough.  But for those seeking "true omnidirectional" speakers along these lines, the Ohm Walsh F technology lived on with a German company, German Physiks who designed their "DDD" driver directly from the old Ohm Walsh F - obviously refined considerably and updated in the light of improved materials (they say as much on their website). 
German Physiks - successor to the
Ohm Walsh F!
I love the idea of German Physiks, too, but the exposed driver of them frankly scares me as far as fingers touching them causing dents or breaks.  Given they have a thin titanium foil driver that is delicate and a carbon fiber one that is supposed to be rugged, you can bet we'd choose the carbon fiber for our situation.  They are making a lot of good press and reviews recently and seem to be a company with growing popularity.  Hmmm ... I am noticing a lot of German companies jumping in to Omni's - I wonder if that means anything? 

MBL is another entry, but I will not spill much ink on them.  Suffice to say they are spectacular sounding, 3D imaging that is legendary and delivers on all the promises, and priced so that only the truly well heeled will ever own them.  Their fragility with their screens off is frightening to us as well.  There are some speakers that would be next to impossible to live with in a typical living room environment, and these might possibly be one of them.  So they would be off of our radar even if they were affordable to regular folks like us.

German MBL Omni's
cost as much as a BMW 6 series
.
Enjoyed by bankers and Tycoons
  But Back to Duevel:  what I like about the Duevel's possibilities are simple.  They have an entry level that qualifies as affordable, because they all are omnidirectional, the whole room (and possibly the next one over) has a chance of experiencing the same sort of stereo presence.  Main negative is they have scant few dealers in the US, and are definitely limited production.  This isn't an issue if you are fantasizing, but if you ever want to turn fantasy into reality, this could be a problem.


The Duevel Bella Luna Diamante
The object of my Omni-crush!
Side Note:  Where the electrostatics will tend to wipe the floor with them (or any speaker using cones) is the clarity and purity of tone, and detail you get when using a single thin sheet of mylar as your transducer instead of thicker multiple drivers.  On the other hand, designers of electrostatics have to jump through hoops in order to allow quality listening to be more than one person at a time.
Look!  Duevels!!  Product placement, or
the producer's pair?

Interestingly enough, the US TV Show "House" - his place had a pair of Duevel speakers.  Talk about audiophile product placement? There has got to be a story there, somewhere.

Duevel Planets - Omnidirectional
speakers that are affordable - and come in
several festive colors!
(Even Chrome)
In any event their whole lineup starts around a kilobuck or so, and ends in the rarefied air aimed at newly minted tycoons and banker's hot with their bonus, like most other audiophile brands.   But what is cool about this and all the omnidirectional speakers is they are offering a solution to the age old problem presented by conventional speakers:  Why should one (or two) people have all the fun?  Maybe one way of getting the whole family in on the action is making sure everyone gets a great seat to the performance?  Food for thought.

I'd love to hear these suckers in action.  Heck, I'd love to hear any of these suckers in action - but the Duevel is currently the object of my obsession!

Comments

  1. When do you get to Sound Labs? As you know, when done right, they are the best of the planars.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Once I can find someone that would be willing to give me a listen that wasn't too far away - we'll both be there!

    ReplyDelete
  3. You're welcome to visit here, but I probably couldn't be further away. On the other hand, the Sonoma County wine country and coast combined with 2 very fine Sound Lab systems couldn't be a better excuse to make the trip.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello Brent. I work for German Physiks. I understand your concern about the vulnerability of the titanium foil driver to straying hands. We have a version of our DDD driver that uses a carbon fibre diaphragm and this is much more rugged as you can see here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2EO4VXfBYFs. The German Physiks model you have illustrated, Unlimited Mk II , is only available with the carbon fibre DDD driver. If you have any questions please drop me a line via our web site at http://www.german-physiks.com/contact.html. Robert Kelly. German Physiks

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the clarification - we are in absolute lust for those speakers as an idea, but have had a fair amount of difficulty actually hearing them. I suppose the are on our "audiophile bucket list."

      Delete
    2. We have played these speakers at the Rocky Mountain Audio Fest for the last couple of years and if we do the show this year we will use them again. At present our participation at the show is yet to be confirmed.

      I am afraid our present US distributor has not been very active in setting up dealers for us which makes it hard for interested customers to get a demonstration. I apologise for this. We are looking for a new and more pro-active distributor.

      There is a very informative review of the Unlimited by Dick Olsher in the Feb 2014 issue of The Absolute Sound. The review should be published on their web site soon.

      We will be at the Axpona Show in Chicago in April. We will have a 5.1 system with Aix Records and Vitus Audio and will use the Borderland (2 models up from the Unlimited) for the rear and centre and the front channels will be our Emperor model. We will also have a custom sub-woofer. This will be quite a big system and we hope to see you at the show.

      Delete
    3. If we can make it out to Axpona, you can bet we will be looking you up - there is something completely magic about omnidirectional speakers, especially the Walsh-style omnis!

      Delete
  5. I totally agree, but you would expect me to say that. I have noticed at shows that people are increasing aware of omnidirectional loudspeakers and appreciative of what they can do. This is encouraging.

    I hope you do make it to Axpona.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hello Brent

    We will be demonstrating the Unlimited Mk IIs in room 1025 at the Rocky Mountain Audio Fest from Oct 10th to 12th. We have dropped the price of these from $13,500 to $9,500, as we have changed how we will work in the US and will have a show special price for orders placed at the show.

    Other news: the Unlimiteds have just received an Absolute Sound Golden Ear award.

    Hope to see you and any other Man Cavers who can make it at the show. All the best, Robert Kelly, German Physiks.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Thorens MM002 and MM008 meet the Crosley C10 (Part 2 of 2)

Full Rez Streaming: Deezer Elite, Murfie and TIDAL on Sonos

The Quad 2805 Review Part1: The Anticipation