Why it isn't all about the Music ... [Rant]
Where he rants a bit ! |
There is something most audiophiles will claim as a truism. There are flame wars over this, but frankly like most things on the internet, it is people shouting at one another with a "stance" rather than trying to find the truth or common ground. When an audiophile, nearly any audiophile, is making this claim, it simply isn't true. What claim, you ask? They say, with nose in the air sometimes, "It is all about the music." If you have stared at an audiophile setup you know right away that this is about as truthful as a politician making a promise on election eve. If you haven't seen them, let me fill you in: A typical audiophile component has a sort of look to it - be it an expensive faceplate, a clear-coat finish, or a speaker with exotic veneer that would make a furniture maker jealous. Cabling (another source of controversy as in "do cables make or fail make a sonic impact" - which is the wrong question, by the way) that is either silvery wispy or a carpet-snake in thickness - all clad in attractive cloth or other material. All of it lavishly made audio jewelry. Pointing this out and what it implies will either get a defensive response or denial most of the time rather than facing the truth they already know or suspect.
Gorgeous, clean looks. From the amazing Jeff's Place Blog This kind of relaxing setup doesn't happen by accident, and with a 'don't give a care' attitude... |
Yes - your emotional state affects the subjective evaluation and enjoyment of music. Don't believe me? Have you ever been "not been in the mood" for something you normally would like. But when you are in the mood you thoroughly enjoy yourself? I'm talking about that phenomenon. The way a fancy restaurant has a decor they set up and maintain is a perfect example - because while food is important, it is not the entire experience of eating at that restaurant. Another example is the way you might bring out a nice set of China for a special meal and light a few candles to enhance the dinner you made. I think many of us treat listening to music like trying to eat a fancy steak on a picnic bench at the town dump or on an unairconditioned city bus in the summer - you can do better to enjoy yourself, and enjoy yourself more by enhancing your surroundings and getting yourself in the mood even if the meal the the same!
Quite possibly the most awesome living room ever! The Speakers are AvantGarde Acoustics - and they cost a small fortune, but are supposed to be terrific! |
But before an audio purist gets their hackles up, I will state it right out there and make it worse for them - it not only works that way, it should work that way. (And incidentally the man-cave sometimes arises out of an extreme misapplication of this idea. You goal isn't to create a diorama of a sound system that is the man-cave stereo - it is to create the environment, and foster the attitudes for the whole family to have a blast listening to music!)
Not to mention being slightly dangerous (See exposed tubes), I am not sure I could ever get in the mood to enjoy music if my rig looked like this? |
But as you build your system with your whole family in mind, remember an important part of the whole experience is the feeling of quality, and attention to detail, music as an event and how cool the system looks. All of it will aid the aesthetic illusion you are trying to create when you play music. Taking a little time to get yourself in the mood, and to get your whole area looking good and set up with care will help you get in the mood more often, and it will greatly enhance you and your families enjoyment. Trust me on this one.
Comments
Post a Comment